By KratomCBDDirect.com Editorial Team
If you've tried kratom, CBD, or other legal options for mood support and relaxation, Amanita mushroom gummies are the newest category worth knowing about. But unlike kratom's alkaloid profile or CBD's effects on the endocannabinoid system, Amanita muscaria works through a completely different mechanism—and the “mushroom gummy” market now includes products with very different active ingredients.
We tested the top options to help you figure out what actually works, how these products stack up against other legal alternatives you might already use, and which ones are worth buying.
How Amanita Muscaria Fits with Other Legal Options
Each legal mood-support option works differently:
Kratom has mitragynine and 7-hydroxymitragynine, which interact with opioid receptors to produce stimulating or sedating effects depending on dose. Legal status varies by state.
CBD works through the endocannabinoid system, affecting receptors tied to mood, pain perception, and stress. Effects are usually subtle and non-impairing.
Kava has kavalactones that affect GABA and other neurotransmitter systems, creating relaxation and mild euphoria. There are some liver concerns at high doses.
Amanita Muscaria has muscimol, a strong GABA-A receptor agonist that produces sedation, relaxation, and altered perception at higher doses. Legal in 49 states (not Louisiana).
Knowing these differences helps you pick products that match what you're actually looking for. Someone who wants daytime focus support needs something completely different than someone looking for evening relaxation.
The Mushroom Gummy Market Decoded
Searching for “amanita mushroom gummies” returns three distinct product types:
Genuine Amanita Muscaria Products: Contain extract from the red-and-white spotted mushroom or isolated muscimol. Produce noticeable psychoactive effects including relaxation, sedation, and enhanced dreams. Legal except in Louisiana.
Functional Mushroom Blends: Contain Lion's Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, and similar species that support cognitive function and immune health. No psychoactive effects—these are daily wellness supplements.
Nootropic Stacks: Combine various mood-supporting compounds like 5-HTP, Rhodiola, and amino acids. May produce mood enhancement through serotonin/dopamine modulation. No actual mushroom extract despite “magic mushroom” marketing.
Top Amanita Muscaria Gummies Ranked
1. Galaxy Treats Moon Shrooms — Best All-Around Option
Galaxy Treats has become the benchmark against which other Amanita products are measured. Each 10-count pack delivers 7,500mg total Amanita extract (750mg per gummy), with ISO 17025-certified lab testing that verifies both potency and safety.
For those familiar with the attention kratom quality requires—testing for alkaloid content, heavy metals, and contaminants—Galaxy Treats applies comparable rigor to Amanita muscaria. Their testing screens for pesticides, residual solvents, mycotoxins, heavy metals, and confirms proper decarboxylation (conversion of ibotenic acid to muscimol).
Effects produce notable GABA-mediated relaxation distinct from either kratom or CBD. Onset occurs within 45-60 minutes, with peak effects at 2-3 hours lasting 4-6 hours total. Users report deep physical relaxation, stress dissolution, and enhanced dream states when taken before sleep.
Comparison to Kratom: Different mechanism entirely. Where kratom's effects involve opioid receptor activity, Amanita muscaria works on GABA receptors. The sedation has a different quality—less euphoric warmth, more profound relaxation.
Comparison to CBD: Significantly more noticeable acute effects. Where CBD produces subtle modulation over time, Amanita muscaria creates obvious state changes within an hour.
Pricing: $37.99 for 10 gummies. 15% subscription discount. Free shipping over $30. 30-day satisfaction guarantee.
Visit Galaxy Treats
2. MoonWlkr Amanita Gummies — Highest Potency
MoonWlkr pushes potency to 1,000mg of Amanita extract per gummy—approximately 33% stronger than Galaxy Treats per piece. For experienced users or those who prefer taking fewer gummies, this concentration delivers efficiency.
The company acknowledges significant individual variation in response, which aligns with what we know about GABA receptor sensitivity differences. Some users report strong effects from half a gummy while others require more. This isn't a quality issue—it's individual biochemistry.
Lab testing confirms potency and purity. Watermelon and Blue Raspberry flavors mask the earthy mushroom taste effectively. The 25% subscription discount represents strong value for regular users.
Pricing: Varies by configuration. 25% subscription savings. Free shipping over $90.
Visit MoonWlkr
3. Premium Jane Muscimol Gummies — Best Precision Option
Premium Jane isolates muscimol rather than using full-spectrum extract, delivering 8mg of pure muscimol per gummy. For those who appreciate kratom alkaloid standardization or CBD isolate products, this pharmaceutical approach resonates.
Research suggests 6-15mg muscimol as the typical effect range, so Premium Jane's 8mg dosing represents a solid starting point with room to increase. The 30-count bottles and 30% subscription discount make this the value leader.
The Peach Raspberry flavor tested best in our evaluations—completely masking any mushroom taste. For those who find kratom powder's flavor challenging, Premium Jane's taste profile is a significant advantage.
Pricing: $35 for 30 gummies ($1.17 each). 30% subscription discount ($0.82 each). Free shipping on all US orders.
Visit Premium Jane
4. ELYXR Amanita Muscaria Gummies — Best Moderate Potency
ELYXR's 500mg-per-gummy formulation suits those who want a gentler introduction to Amanita muscaria. The candy-coated “Sprinkled” format delivers superior taste, and the moderate potency allows careful dose titration.
For CBD users accustomed to low-and-slow dosing approaches, ELYXR's concentration enables similar methodology with Amanita muscaria. Start with one gummy, assess effects, and adjust from there.
Pricing: $27.99 for 10-count packs. Free shipping over $169.
Visit ELYXR
Functional Mushroom Alternatives
These products contain no Amanita muscaria and produce no psychoactive effects. They're included here for comprehensive comparison.
Pilly Labs Mushroom Extract Complex — Best Daily Functional Support
Pilly Labs combines 10 functional mushroom species—Lion's Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Chaga, Turkey Tail, Maitake, Shiitake, White Button, Black Fungus, and Royal Sun—using fruiting body extracts at 10:1 concentration.
Critical distinction: This is NOT an Amanita muscaria product and produces NO psychoactive effects. It's comparable to daily vitamin supplementation rather than acute mood-altering compounds like kratom or Amanita.
The value lies in long-term support for cognitive function, immune health, and adaptogenic resilience. For those already taking CBD for general wellness, Pilly Labs addresses complementary systems through different mechanisms.
Best For: Daily wellness support. Take before work, driving, or any activity requiring full alertness. No contraindication with most other supplements.
TRĒ House Magic Mushroom Gummies — Nootropic Stack
Despite the name, TRĒ House contains no Amanita muscaria, no psilocybin, and no psychedelic mushroom extracts. Their product uses a nootropic blend: 5-HTP, Rhodiola Rosea, Lion's Mane, Mimosa Hostilis Root, Phenylethylamine, and B vitamins.
This stack may produce mood enhancement through serotonin and dopamine pathway modulation. Users report experiences ranging from notable euphoria to no perceptible effects. Those on SSRI medications typically experience minimal results due to 5-HTP interactions.
For those seeking mood support while specifically avoiding GABA-active compounds like kratom or Amanita, TRĒ House offers a different approach. Just understand you're buying a nootropic supplement, not a mushroom extract.
Visit TRĒ House
Comparison Chart: How Amanita Stacks Up
Amanita Muscaria (Muscimol)
- Mechanism: GABA-A receptor agonism
- Onset: 45-90 minutes
- Duration: 4-6 hours
- Primary Effects: Sedation, relaxation, dream enhancement
- Legal Status: Legal in 49 states (Louisiana excepted)
- Drug Testing: Not detected on standard panels
Kratom (Mitragynine/7-OH)
- Mechanism: Opioid receptor modulation
- Onset: 15-30 minutes
- Duration: 3-5 hours
- Primary Effects: Dose-dependent stimulation or sedation
- Legal Status: Varies by state, federally unscheduled
- Drug Testing: Some specialized panels detect alkaloids
CBD (Cannabidiol)
- Mechanism: Endocannabinoid system modulation
- Onset: 30-90 minutes (edibles)
- Duration: 4-8 hours
- Primary Effects: Subtle relaxation, stress support
- Legal Status: Federally legal under 0.3% THC
- Drug Testing: Full-spectrum may cause THC positives
Kava (Kavalactones)
- Mechanism: GABA and other neurotransmitter modulation
- Onset: 20-30 minutes
- Duration: 2-4 hours
- Primary Effects: Relaxation, mild euphoria
- Legal Status: Legal, some liver safety concerns at high doses
- Drug Testing: Not detected on standard panels
Combination Considerations
For those who use multiple legal alternatives, understanding interactions matters:
Amanita + CBD: Theoretically combinable as mechanisms don't directly overlap. Start with reduced doses of both. The GABA sedation from Amanita may compound any relaxation from CBD.
Amanita + Kratom: Exercise caution. Both produce sedation through different mechanisms, and combination could amplify effects beyond intended levels. If attempting, use significantly reduced doses of both.
Amanita + Kava: Both affect GABA systems. Combination not recommended due to potential for excessive CNS depression.
Amanita + Alcohol: Not recommended. Overlapping GABA mechanisms can produce dangerous sedation levels.
Amanita + Functional Mushrooms (Pilly Labs): No contraindication. Functional mushrooms work through entirely different mechanisms with no acute psychoactive effects.
Dosing Guide for Alternative Wellness Enthusiasts
If You're Sensitive to Substances Generally:
- Start with 250-375mg Amanita extract (half a standard gummy)
- Or 4mg muscimol (half a Premium Jane gummy)
- Wait 90+ minutes before considering more
If You Have Experience with Kratom/Kava:
- You're familiar with botanical variability
- Start with 500-750mg extract (one Galaxy Treats gummy)
- Or 8mg muscimol (one Premium Jane gummy)
- Effects will feel different than what you know—GABA sedation vs. opioid modulation
If You're Seeking Strong Effects:
- Build up gradually over multiple sessions
- MoonWlkr's 1,000mg gummies suit experienced users
- Never start at high doses regardless of tolerance to other substances
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I rotate Amanita muscaria with kratom?
Some users report rotating different legal alternatives to prevent tolerance to any single substance. If rotating, allow at least 24 hours between different compounds and never combine them in the same session.
Which is stronger: Amanita or kratom?
Different effects rather than stronger/weaker. Kratom's alkaloids produce effects through opioid receptor activity; Amanita's muscimol works on GABA receptors. The sedation qualities differ substantially.
Will Amanita muscaria show up if I'm tested for kratom?
No. Kratom-specific tests look for mitragynine metabolites. Muscimol is chemically unrelated and wouldn't trigger such tests.
Are functional mushroom gummies (like Pilly Labs) a good alternative if I can't use Amanita?
They serve different purposes. Functional mushrooms support health over time without acute effects. They won't replace the immediate relaxation that Amanita muscaria provides but offer legitimate wellness benefits through different mechanisms.
How does TRĒ House compare to actual Amanita products?
TRĒ House contains no mushroom extracts whatsoever—it's a nootropic blend. Effects (if any) come from 5-HTP and other compounds affecting serotonin/dopamine rather than GABA. Different mechanism, different experience.
Bottom Line Recommendations
For Quality and Safety: Galaxy Treats Moon Shrooms — Comprehensive testing, consistent potency, 30-day guarantee.
For Value: Premium Jane Muscimol Gummies — Best cost-per-serving with precise dosing.
For Potency: MoonWlkr — 1,000mg per gummy for experienced users.
For Daily Wellness Support: Pilly Labs — Functional mushrooms for cognitive/immune support without psychoactive effects.
Whatever you choose, approach Amanita muscaria as you would any new botanical—start low, assess response, and respect the compound's potency. The GABA mechanism produces effects distinct from kratom, CBD, or other alternatives you may have experience with.
Disclaimer: These products are not FDA-approved and are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Individual responses vary. Consult healthcare providers before use, especially if taking medications or managing health conditions.
Leave a Reply